This article will contain discussion of sexual assault and violence against children, if that’s something you’d prefer to avoid.
There are movies that, thanks to their reputations, just never quite die off. Movies that become a way to test your cinematic mettle, to make it through the nastiest stuff imaginable, to prove that you’re capable of handling the most extreme horror imaginable. Megan is Missing is one of those movies.
Released in 2011, Megan is Missing is a low-budget horror written and directed by Michael Goi, following the story of Amy (Amber Perkins), a young teenager who investigates the vanishing of her best friend Megan (Rachel Quinn) after interacting with a stranger online.
I’m a lover of found footage and someone with a continued (if occasionally ill-advised) interest in extreme horror films, so Megan is Missing is one that I crossed paths with not long after it came out. It was one of those movies that I watched when it came out, and truly never expected to hear about again – because it’s honestly fucking dreadful. The first half is a dreadfully-written attempt to capture the “reality” of life for young teenage girls, a finger-wagging PSA about taking drugs and drinking and going to parties that’s borderline-parody in its complete lack of nuance or subtlety. There are a few gestures in the direction of criticising true crime reportage that come across more like bad attempts at comedy than anything else, and then the movie lurches into its infamous third act, after the titular Megan goes Missing. It’s about twenty minutes of torture, including a three-minute-long graphic rape scene of a thirteen-year-old character, before her eventual violent death. The only thing that’s got any kind of value from a filmmaking perspective, to my eyes, is the pretty solid make-up job on Megan’s corpse in the film’s final scene, but that’s just not even remotely enough to justify this grotty, badly-made movie’s existence in the first place.
But, despite how boring, ugly, and grim the film is, it’s consistently been in the conversation as one of the most disturbing horror films of all time – and, as a result, sees waves of interest as new horror fans discover it for the first time. A new surge of interest in 2020 led to a recent sequel, also written and directed by Goi, and I have finally decided it’s time to get off my arse and have a good old rant about why I hate this dreadful movie quite as much as I do.
If that’s all this film was – a poor-taste, poor-quality bottom-of-the-barrel (pun intended) exploitation flick that would be left to the annals of time, as it should be – it probably wouldn’t bother me as much as it does. But Goi has framed the movie as some attempt to contend with the threat of child abuse posed by predators, both online and in real life. In a director’s statement on the film’s original website, he claimed to have created the concept for the movie from a place of “rage, frustration, and sorrow” after increased reports of cases of child sexual abuse; on his reasoning for making the movie, he wrote “ultimately, I guess I’d like to defeat the kind of evil that motivates someone to take the life of a child. Evil thrives in this world if you allow it to. And to defeat evil, you first have to know what evil is. MEGAN IS MISSING is me, and now you, staring evil in the face”.
And it’s exactly that bombastic and exploitative tone that I feel takes this movie from “trashy, grim exploitation” straight into “downright fucking dreadful”. Goi claims to have intended to present the movie as a straightforward and honest depiction of what happens to victims of internet predation – and I think that, even with the extreme violence in the third act, maybe that could have worked if the rest of the film made an effort to depict the lives of the victims in a way that actually felt real. As a person who was actually a teenage girl at the time the film was shot, I can tell you in no uncertain terms that the first hour or so of the movie, in the build-up to the Great Big Torture Session, is about as far from reality as they could get – cartoonishly catty teen girls talking about their crushes on celebrities who are certainly timely and relevant to the modern age and not just the last heartthrobs Goi distantly remembered hearing about. Despite Goi’s claims that he drew the dialogue from actual conversations he’d had with friends’ children, there’s a distinct lack of realism in the interactions between characters and the social scene of the young teenagers; the discovery of the video camera containing the footage of the torture, rape, and murder of the main character is never satisfactorily explained, nor is the news footage particularly well-wrought or convincing.
Which leaves the only thing that does feel like a true attempt at realism the sexual and physical violence enacted on the child characters; and look, I cannot say for certain what a creator’s intentions were when putting a particular scene to screen, but it’s hard not to contrast the graphic and prolonged nature of the assaults with the plot holes and overall poor quality of the rest of the movie. If this was truly about realism, then why does that only seem to have been applied to the last twenty minutes or so?
And then there’s the production of the film itself, which I take some issue with too. Rachel Quinn, who played Megan, was seventeen when the film was shot in the mid-2000s, and, while Goi made it clear that he had family members present on set during the shooting of her scenes, there are a few aspects that clearly dip into the inappropriate. Quinn is pictured in a pillory table during the movie, and, for a film which set out to criticize the sexual abuse of children online, producing and publishing images of a child actor in a fetish device seems like a misstep that would be laughable if it weren’t so fucking horrible (Quinn herself described shooting these pictures as the hardest part of her time on set, recalling bursting into tears when she was shown the images they were recreating). Goi has claimed that “the dialogue was entirely transcribed from audio and video recordings [he] made of friends’ children”, which presumably also includes a protracted scene where one of the child characters describe a sexual assault enacted on her by a camp counsellor in great, unbroken detail in a scene that lasts several minutes.
And strangest of all is that Goi himself claims that the movie is not intended for children – which is to say, the very people that he claims he was trying to protect with this film. In a 2020 interview, he remarked on the matter of kids finding his film – “I remember the first time that it started trending up on YouTube years ago, an 11-year-old contacted me, and she says, “Wow, now I understand what my mom has been telling me about being on the internet. I didn’t understand it until I watched your movie.” And I said, “What are you doing watching my movie?” There’s no way an 11-year-old should be watching this movie”. And that, to me, is just so bizarre – not that I think this movie should be shown to kids, because it’s clearly too disturbing, but because a film that intended to educate on the threat of online predators against children should, surely, be appropriate for them to watch. There’s an argument to be made that it’s intended to warn adults of the seriousness of this threat to encourage them to take greater precaution for the young people in their lives, but the fact that Goi didn’t even intend it for the people he wanted to protect feels like an obvious shot in the foot to the film’s purported purpose.
Megan is Missing is a movie I truly hate on all levels – it’s a dreadfully-made film, badly-written and terribly acted, and the high-handed claims that it’s an attempt to contend in unflinching detail with real-life crimes against children are blatantly undercut by the lack of effort put into anything but the sexual and physical violence. It’s an exploitation flick in the most literal sense of the word, and the sooner it drops from the mainstream, the better.
If you enjoyed this article and want to see more stuff like it, please consider supporting us on Ko-Fi. You can check out more of my work on my personal blog, The Cutprice Guignol!
By Lou MacGregor